Social Media for Development: Exploring the potential of social media to reduce poverty and advance justice.

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

Social Media for Social Justice

Much has been written about how social media was used to organize the riots in Vancouver after the Canucks lost to the Boston Bruins in the Stanley Cup Final. But here's an example of a more positive use of social media - trying to save a potentially innocent man's life.

Last week, supporters of Troy Davis mobilized an international social media campaign to save him from the death penalty. Davis was convicted of killing a police officer in 1989. Since then, seven of the nine witnesses against him have recanted their testimony, saying they felt pressured by the police to name Davis as the killer.

His supporters, including the NAACP, the Coalition to End the Death Penalty, and Amnesty International, organized a social media campaign called #TooMuchDoubt. Amnesty urged people to change their Facebook pictures with photos of Davis with the words Too Much Doubt written across it. The NAACP also launched an "I am Troy Davis" campaign via Facebook and Twitter.

But the power of social media has its limits. It can be much easier to organize a fruitless riot than to right an apparent injustice.

Sadly, Davis lost his last appeal today before the Georgia Board of Pardons and Paroles. He is slated for execution on Wednesday. While his supporters may have succeeded in mobilizing support for Davis, they appear to have lost the battle to save his life. According an AFP article, not even the governor of Georgia has the power to save him.

What does this have to do with social media for development? Not much directly, unless you consider the quest for social justice to be an aspect of development. We think of development in terms so-called Third World nations, but we in the so-called first world have not perfected our political and legal institutions either. They need to be further developed.

I don't know if Davis is guilty or not, but there appears to be enough reasonable doubt to at least spare his life. And, for the record, I am not opposed to the idea of a death penalty. I don't believe that Clifford Olsen and Paul Bernardo should be breathing the same air as the rest of us. But I'm not sure the death penalty can function as it should in a deeply flawed justice system.

If he is put to death on Wednesday, Davis's supporters need not feel they have failed him. If Davis is not guilty, then the American justice system has failed him instead. Civil society actors such as Amnesty did succeed in mobilizing support for Davis, and the lessons learned may pay off in future cases. The lessons learned may also assist civil society mobilize social media for other causes as well.

2 comments:

  1. Interesting POV Frank. I've followed this over the past couple of days. There is lots of media attention about the history of this case, the witnesses recanting, etc. There is also an editorial I read yesterday (I wish I could find it today) written by one of the prosecution lawyers in the case. He explains, in his opinion, why Davis is guilty, why the execution should take place and provides the arguments for his opinion, including arguments from court. I haven't made up my mind if Davis is guilty or innocent, but I find it interesting now that with all of the social media attention and news media covering it, the pro-execution arguments appear to be getting overwhelmed by the anti-execution. In other words, it's easy to find opinions from people who want to stop the execution, but it's not easy to find the other opinions.

    If I find that link to the editorial again, I'll send it to you.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks, Brian. Yes, I'd like to see that commentary if you can find it.

    It's easier to find opinions against the execution because the issue fits within the broader mandate of organizations such as Amnesty and the NAACP. This was a highly coordinated rather than a grassroots social media campaign.

    I don't know if Davis is guilty or not - but so many witnesses' recanting gives me pause.

    ReplyDelete